How to Buy


We offer buyers multiple payment options on items listed in our secure Etsy store including credit card, debit card, and Etsy Gift Card.

For items not listed in our Etsy store, we accept major credit cards, CASH, personal checks ($50 dollar returned check fee), and U.S. Post Office money orders.  Make payments payable to: Mr. Timothy Matero (aka:The Pierceton Picker).  

It’s easy to shop with The Pierceton Picker!

1. Local Shop and Pick Up
Email and we will gladly set up a convenient time for you to visit our Warsaw, Indiana repository to inspect the item and complete your purchase.

Need directions? Click here.

The repository is open by appointment only, Monday through Saturday. Evening hours are no problem.

2. Shop online securely at our Etsy store.

Please note:

We can ship your paid in full items at your direction, and selection of carriers, provided shipping is paid in advance. Simply or email to make arrangements.

Please note that all offerings are sold “as is” due to the age of the items. No warranties of any kind are extended. No refunds, exchanges or credits without prior approval. Returned items subject to 15% restocking fee. Shipping costs are non-refundable.

Sales taxes are added to the final purchase price. Barter and trade deals at our discretion.

Click here for complete policies and payment details.